Moritz's response confirmed one of Alice’s fears. He did not believe the entire story, it was too rushed, too cobbled together, and conflicted with prior information she had given just moments before. Stupid. Stupid. Stupid. She should have predicted that something like this would happen eventually. Someone would get curious and ask why she was hanging around and she should have had a good believable excuse. Tracking a lost lover, avenging her death, something solid and easily believable but she instead tried to play fast and loose, keying the young spiritist into some of her motives because she did quite like them. Stupid and foolhardy, which would only make her life more difficult later down the line.
“I was originally from Syliras. And you are correct my family and life aren’t in Sunberth. I left because I don’t want to be a ghost for my family. I wish to be Alice and it's quite easy to be caught up on me being dead. My travels are only temporary, I hope until I figure something out that works for everyone.” She could hope that would be enough to tide Moritz over until she could get her thoughts and story in line but she doubted that. The endless curiosity she found endearing was quickly revealing itself to be a problem.
But he seemed to shift quickly enough away from her weak story and jump into talking about his mother which spun into a quite philosophical view of morality and the like. The more he spoke about his mother the less of a decent person she seemed. Willing to commit great sacrifice on others even when it wasn’t necessary to just gain a tiny bit more. Alice did find Mortitz’s idea on multiple paths greatly attractive. Never was someone limited to two or fewer options there was always another path that one could take. She had to believe in that as well since she was trying to take a different path than many others before her. As for his comment on that, what if someone’s ulterior motive was to just be a good person? Would anyone truly disagree with them living their life like that?
“If someone's ulterior motive was just to simply be the best person they could be, help those around them, and make sure their choices cause the least amount of suffering...I think the world would be much better off. But alas I don’t think that'll ever happen. There might be a few but not enough to make a difference because they will be taken advantage of and abused out of that line of thinking. A few bad apples spoil the bunch so to say. A noble cause, however, that is a nice way to think about life.”
Then Mortiz got to essentially the heart of the matter of why they met up again. To continue their discussion on truth. Ironic because she just started their conversation off with a lie… He gave a brief outline of what he believed that people lied because they either think less of the person or seek to gain something out of it.
“The truth is such a fickle thing isn't it?” She mused reaching down and brushed a hand across a fork, coating it in a bit of her shroud, picked it up and spun it between her materialized fingers like one would roll a pencil, gathering her thoughts. “Truth has so many forms and an individual's truth varies from one person to another greatly. People try to distill what the truth is through science, math, and repeated study but I feel truth is much more individualized. Like art or magic in that regard. You could hand two people the same tools, and give the same instructions, such as to carve a bird, and you would get two different carvings. Perhaps one would carve a duck while the other a passing songbird. Both completed the task, both carved a bird, both are fundamentally the same yet not.Lying is adapting yourself to someone's truth, you try to match what you think their carving would be. It can be done for a variety of reasons such as softening a blow, giving encouragement to push someone past their limits, or just to avoid danger.”
“An example of lying for encouragement would be if you’ve ever tried to do something or learn something such as maths yet you were doing terribly at it. Instead of telling you the truth that you are terrible at maths and by extension crush your spirit the teacher instead lies. Twists their truth to yours and creates a new truth by saying ‘You are doing great!’ --the truth you want to hear-- but follows it with “but here are some issues that you could work on’ --what their truth is--. That didn’t seem like a lie did it not? But it was. They wrapped their truth in your truth to soften the blow. Lying is everywhere because if one never adapted to another’s truth nothing would ever get done. We don’t like to admit it but we are all imperfect and hate more than anything to be reminded of it.”
“I am not trying to argue that people don’t lie because they don’t think someone is lesser than them or the fact that they stand to gain something from it. I am just saying that lying does have its place and is very prevalent because people’s internal truths are inherently different and we would struggle to work together otherwise.”
“I was originally from Syliras. And you are correct my family and life aren’t in Sunberth. I left because I don’t want to be a ghost for my family. I wish to be Alice and it's quite easy to be caught up on me being dead. My travels are only temporary, I hope until I figure something out that works for everyone.” She could hope that would be enough to tide Moritz over until she could get her thoughts and story in line but she doubted that. The endless curiosity she found endearing was quickly revealing itself to be a problem.
But he seemed to shift quickly enough away from her weak story and jump into talking about his mother which spun into a quite philosophical view of morality and the like. The more he spoke about his mother the less of a decent person she seemed. Willing to commit great sacrifice on others even when it wasn’t necessary to just gain a tiny bit more. Alice did find Mortitz’s idea on multiple paths greatly attractive. Never was someone limited to two or fewer options there was always another path that one could take. She had to believe in that as well since she was trying to take a different path than many others before her. As for his comment on that, what if someone’s ulterior motive was to just be a good person? Would anyone truly disagree with them living their life like that?
“If someone's ulterior motive was just to simply be the best person they could be, help those around them, and make sure their choices cause the least amount of suffering...I think the world would be much better off. But alas I don’t think that'll ever happen. There might be a few but not enough to make a difference because they will be taken advantage of and abused out of that line of thinking. A few bad apples spoil the bunch so to say. A noble cause, however, that is a nice way to think about life.”
Then Mortiz got to essentially the heart of the matter of why they met up again. To continue their discussion on truth. Ironic because she just started their conversation off with a lie… He gave a brief outline of what he believed that people lied because they either think less of the person or seek to gain something out of it.
“The truth is such a fickle thing isn't it?” She mused reaching down and brushed a hand across a fork, coating it in a bit of her shroud, picked it up and spun it between her materialized fingers like one would roll a pencil, gathering her thoughts. “Truth has so many forms and an individual's truth varies from one person to another greatly. People try to distill what the truth is through science, math, and repeated study but I feel truth is much more individualized. Like art or magic in that regard. You could hand two people the same tools, and give the same instructions, such as to carve a bird, and you would get two different carvings. Perhaps one would carve a duck while the other a passing songbird. Both completed the task, both carved a bird, both are fundamentally the same yet not.Lying is adapting yourself to someone's truth, you try to match what you think their carving would be. It can be done for a variety of reasons such as softening a blow, giving encouragement to push someone past their limits, or just to avoid danger.”
“An example of lying for encouragement would be if you’ve ever tried to do something or learn something such as maths yet you were doing terribly at it. Instead of telling you the truth that you are terrible at maths and by extension crush your spirit the teacher instead lies. Twists their truth to yours and creates a new truth by saying ‘You are doing great!’ --the truth you want to hear-- but follows it with “but here are some issues that you could work on’ --what their truth is--. That didn’t seem like a lie did it not? But it was. They wrapped their truth in your truth to soften the blow. Lying is everywhere because if one never adapted to another’s truth nothing would ever get done. We don’t like to admit it but we are all imperfect and hate more than anything to be reminded of it.”
“I am not trying to argue that people don’t lie because they don’t think someone is lesser than them or the fact that they stand to gain something from it. I am just saying that lying does have its place and is very prevalent because people’s internal truths are inherently different and we would struggle to work together otherwise.”